1. Do you like Nick or Amy? Did you find yourself picking a side?
Do you think the author intends for us to like them? Why or why not?
2. Does the author intend for us to think of Nick or Amy as the stronger
writer? Do you perceive one or the other as a stronger writer, based on
their narration/journal entries? Why?
3. Do you think Amy and Nick both believe in their marriage at the
outset?
4. Nick, ever conscious of the way he is being perceived, reflects on
the images that people choose to portray in the world—constructed,
sometimes plagiarized roles that we present as our personalities.
Discuss the ways in which the characters—and their opinions of each
other—are influenced by our culture’s avid consumption of TV shows,
movies, and websites, and our need to fit each other into these roles.
5. Discuss Amy’s false diary, both as a narrative strategy by the author
and as a device used by the character. How does the author use it to
best effect? How does Amy use it?
6. What do you make of Nick’s seeming paranoia on the day of his fifth
anniversary, when he wakes with a start and reports feeling, You have
been seen?
7. As experienced consumers of true crime and tragedy, modern
“audiences” tend to expect each crime to fit a specific mold: a story, a
villain, a heroine. How does this phenomenon influence the way we judge
news stories? Does it have an impact on the criminal justice system?
Consider the example of the North Carthage police, and also Tanner
Bolt’s ongoing advice to Nick.
8. What is Go’s role in the book? Why do you think the author wrote her
as Nick’s twin? Is she a likable character?
9. Discuss Amy’s description of the enduring myth of the "cool girl"—and
her conviction that a male counterpart (seemingly flawless to women)
does not exist. Do you agree? Why does she assume the role if she seems
to despise it? What benefit do you think she derives from the act?
10. Is there some truth to Amy’s description of the "dancing
monkeys"—her friends' hapless partners who are forced to make sacrifices
and perform “sweet” gestures to prove their love? How is this a
counterpoint to the “cool girl”?
11. What do you think of Marybeth and Rand Elliott? Is the image they
present sincere? What do you think they believe about Amy?
12. How does the book deal with the divide between perception and
reality, or between public image and private lives? Which characters are
most skillful at navigating this divide, and how?
13. How does the book capture the feel of the recession—the ending of
jobs and contraction of whole industries; economic and geographical
shifts; real estate losses and abandoned communities. Are some of Nick
and Amy’s struggles emblematic of the time period? Are there any parts
of the story that feel unique to this time period?
14. While in hiding, Amy begins to explore what the "real" Amy likes and
dislikes. Do you think this is a true exploration of her feelings, or is
she acting out yet another role? In these passages, what does she mean
when she refers to herself as “I” in quotes?
15. What do you think of Amy’s quizzes—and "correct" answers—that appear
throughout the book? As a consistent thread between her Amazing Amy
childhood and her adult career, what does her quiz-writing style reveal
about Amy’s true personality and her understanding of the world?
16. Do Nick and Amy have friends? Consider Nick’s assurance that Noelle
was deluded in her claims of friendship with Amy, and also the friends
described in Amy’s journal. How "rea" are these friendships? What do you
think friendship means to each of them?
17. What was the relationship between Amy and Nick’s father? Do you
think the reader is meant to imagine conversations between the two of
them? Why does Nick’s father come to Nick and Amy’s home?
18. Amy publicly denounces the local police and criticizes their
investigation. Do you think they did a good job of investigating her
disappearance? Were there real missteps, or was their failing due to
Amy’s machinations?
19. Do you believe Amy truly would have committed suicide? Why does she
return?
20. Were you satisfied with the book’s ending? What do you think the
future holds for Nick, Amy, and their baby boy?