| Pro | Joni | Camilleri | The sensible one. |
| | Deborah | Camden | The straight shooter. Aka: Debbie, Deb. |
| | Trina | Chan | The restrained one. |
| | Eden Elizabeth | Chester | The musician. |
| 1 | Matt | O'Reilly | The priest Jodi confessed to. |
| 2 | Mrs. | Gamble | Homeroom teacher. |
| 3 | Benjamin | | Eden's husband. Aka: Ben. |
| | Leif | | Eden's child. |
| | Connor | | Civil engineer. Deb's husband. |
| | Ruby | | Deb's daughter. |
| | Josh | | Trina's husband. |
| | Maisie | | Eden's daughter. |
| | Nate | | Trina's son. |
| | Kai | | Joni's husband. |
| | Luke | Berry | Joni's crush in high school. |
| | Joseph | | Luke's buddy. |
| | Kelly | Cropley | Hosted the formal after party. |
| | Kendra | Williams | Basketball player in high school. |
| | Pete | | The head chef at Bellacinos. |
| | Steve | Highbury | A high school senior. |
| 5 | Celine | Avenue | The name Joni used to come up with her pseudonym. |
| | Celine | Fletcher | Joni's pseudonym. |
| 7 | Budgie | | Joni's pet bird. |
| 9 | Brett | | Rock-climbing guide. |
| 10 | Jared | | The guy Eden dated in high school. |
| 13 | Rochelle | MacDonald | The girl who got into an accident on her birthday. |
| | Sunny | | The paramedic who helped Joni. |
| 16 | Aimee | | Sale representative for 'The Thermomix'. |
| | Jan | Chester | Eden's mother. |
| 17 | Clarke | | The one who took advantage of Eden. |
| | Jared | | The guy Eden dated in high school. |
| | Mr. | Arlington | Clarke's father. |
| 21 | Sage | | Deb's new baby. |
| Epi | Greg | Henderson | Jodi's classmate in high school. |
| | Chad | Forbes | Hottest guy in school for Deb. |
| | Mr. | Gallea | Design and tech teacher. |
