| 1 | Chanel | Rylan | Victim. Actress and part-time waitress at Broadway Babies. |
| | Lola | Kawaski | Chanel's best friend. A veterenarian. |
| | Eve | Dallas | Protagonist. Lieutenant. |
| | Art | Roarke | Eve's husband. |
| | Galahad | | Eve's cat. |
| | Delia | Peabody | Police detective. Eve's partner. |
| | | Mcnab | Delia's co-investigator. |
| | Damien | Forsythe | Chanel's ex-boyfriend. Actor. |
| | Carmine | | A sweet, little poodle. Lola's patient. |
| | Gloria | | Lola's vet assistant. |
| | Carter | | |
| | Lori | | |
| | Mark | Snyder | Film student. Was in the theater when the incident happened. |
| 2 | Annalisa | Bacardo | Officer in charge of Broadway Babies. |
| | Giavanni | | Annalisa's assistant. |
| | Micha | | Broadway Babies bartender. Chanel's close friend. |
| | Teresa | | Broadway Babies sous chef. Chanel's close friend. |
| | Eliza | | Chanel's co-waitress and close friend. |
| 3 | Justin | Jackson | Annalisa's lover. |
| 4 | Dr. | Morris | Eve's close friend. |
| | Charlotte | Mira | NYPSD psychiatrist. |
| | Reineke | | Jenkinson's partner. |
| | Jessilyn | Brooke | Chanel's competition for a role. |
| | Nadine | Furst | Channel 75 anchor desk. |
| | Blaine | Delano | Serial Killer series author. Nadine's casual friend. |
| | Santiago | | Homicide detective. |
| 5 | Amelia | Benson | Chanel's former role. A fictional character. |
| | Heather | Delano | Blaine's daughter. |
| | Piper | Delano | Blaine's daughter. |
| | Deann | Dark | Blaine's character in her Dark Falls book. Former police detective. |
| | Craig | Jefferson | Blaine's former husband. |
| | Quilla | Magnum | Journalism student. A possible candidate for Nadine's internship. |
| | Jenkinson | | NYPSD police detective. |
| | Rosie | Kent | A victim from Jenkinson's case. Deceased. |
| | Olivia | Diaz | Retired detective. |
| 6 | Dennis | Mira | Charlotte's husband. |
| | Devon | Monrow | Lola's neighbor. Costume designer. |
| | Sampson | | Dog in a pet clinic near the theater. |
| | Mrs. | Pinky | Vet in a pet clinic near the theater. |
| 7 | David | Reingold | Man in the theater. |
| | Missy | | Jessilyn's roommate. |
| | Hank | | Jessilyn's roommate. |
| | Audrey | Delano | Blaine's mother. |
| 8 | Brady | Mishner | Boy who has a sexy eye. |
| | Britta | Gleason | Girl who has a sexy eye. |
| | Mattie | Jefferson | Craig's wife. |
| | Craig | Jefferson Jr. | Craig and Mattie's son. aka: CJ. |
| | Stan | Grotti | Craig's lawyer. |
| 9 | Pryor | Carridine | The victim in Blaine's mystery novel. |
| | | Summerset | Roarke's majordomo. |
| 10 | Aaron Edward | Strongbow | Somebody who admires Blaine's mystery books. Also a writer. |
| | Chris | Bundy | Somebody who admires Blaine's mystery books. |
| | Andre | Mendini | Underrated painter. |
| 11 | Jake | Kincade | Band member. |
| 12 | Carmichael | | Police detective. Eve's colleague. |
| | Loxie | Flash | One of the girls on the Skank List. Aka: Marianna Beliski. |
| | Leonardo | Freestone | High-end designer. Mavis's husband. |
| | Mavis | Freestone | Eve's best friend. |
| | Maggie | Dark | A character in Blaine's book. |
| | Gia | | Seamstress. |
| | Bliss | Catcher | Victim in Blaine's book. |
| 13 | Clint | Harcove | Police detective. |
| | Shanna | K. | One of the girls on the Skank List. |
| | Karleen | | Button World's manager. |
| 14 | Sherwood | | Owner of Button World. |
| | Lydia | | Button World clerk. |
| | Yola | Bloomfield | OP-x Artist. Possibly the next victim. |
| | Stone | Bailey | Somebody the killer is obsessed with. Yola's ex-boyfriend. |
| | Brady | Smithers | Screw U bartender. |
| 15 | Janis | Dorsey | Loxie's friend. |
| | Adam | Glazier | Glaze Band's lead guitarist. Loxie's ex-boyfriend. aka: Glaze. |
| | Bennie | | A random man Loxie seduced at the club. |
| | Malted | | Screw U bouncer. |
| | Sasha | Quint | Screw U bartender. |
| | Dorinda | | Screw U waitress. |
| | Shelby | | NYPSD police officer. |
| | Dodo | | Janis's friend. |
| | Sylvio | | Hair designer. Saw the killer at Screw U. |
| 17 | Lauren | | Glaze's girlfriend. |
| | Harvo | | NYPSD crime lab tech. |
| 18 | Feeney | | NYPSD police officer. |
| | Rocky | | Jake's drummer. |
| 19 | | Trueheart | NYPSD police officer. |
| | Bella | | Leonardo's daughter. aka: Bellissima Freestone. |
| | Ann Elizabeth | Smithers | The woman who matched the sketch of the possible suspect. |
| 20 | Callendar | | NYPSD police officer. |
| | Gracie | Lipwitch | The woman who lives in Ann Elizabeth's address. |
| | Darby | Lipwitch | Gracie's daughter. |
| | Jill | | Works at Fancy Dress. |
| | Mrs. | Waterstone | Gracie's neighbor. |
| 21 | Conchita | Gomez | Dobb's supervisor. aka: Cheeta. |
| | Yolanda | | Ann Elizabeth's former co-worker. |
| | Lt. | Mcmahon | NYPSD police officer. |
| | Natalia | Durban Berkle | Ann Elizabeth's customer. |
| 22 | Paullette | | Woman at the concierge desk. |
| | Earnestine | | Ms. Berkle's personal assistant. |
| | Dru | Berkle | Natalia's daughter. |
| | Marsha | | Berkle's servant. |
| | Sal | | Ms. Berkle's sister-in-law. |
| | Felicity | Lomare | Ann Elizabeth's employer. Ms. Berkle's friend. |
