| | | | 2004 |
| | Wade | Mitchell | Ann Mitchell's wife. |
| | Jenny | Mitchell | Wade Mitchell's first wife. |
| | Ann | Mitchell | Wade Mitchell's new wife / A Choir Teacher in Idaho. |
| | May | Mitchell | Jenny and Wade Mitchell's daughter. |
| | June | Mitchell | Jenny and Wade Mitchell's daughter / Eliot's friend. aka: Lily. |
| | Eliot | Mitchell | Student in Ann Mitchell's Choir Class / June Mitchell's friend. |
| | Claire | | Librarian in Sage Hill Women's Correctional Center. |
| | Miller | | A Grocery Store Owner. |
| | Gina | | A woman that Ann Mitchell met in the trailer. |
| | | | 2008 |
| | Elizabeth | | Jenny Mitchell's cellmate. |
| | Mr. | Abram | Elizabeth's teacher. |
| | Mr. | Damiani | Elizabeth's teacher. |
| | Sylvia | | Elizabeth's old cellmate and bestfriend. |
| | | | 1985-1986 |
| | Adam | Mitchell | Wade Mitchell's father who has dementia. |
| | June Bailey | Roe | Woman receives money - Wade Mitchell's demented father. |
| | | | 1995 |
| | Rocket | | May Mitchell's orange tabby cat. |
| | | | 2006 |
| | Alana | Onbrook | A woman who ran away from her home. |
| | Jim | Lee | A Seattle resident who recognized Alana Onbrook. |
| | Tom | Clark | Alana Onbrook's cousin. An artist who helps find June Mitchell. |
| | | | NCMEC - National Center for Missing & Exploited Children. |
| | Diana | Segal | Tom Clark's Art Teacher and Mentor. |
| | Tracy | Onbrook | Alana Onbrook's mother. |
| | | | 1973 |
| | Grant | Warner | Wade Mitchell's boss. Owner of farm where Mitchell worked. |
| | Rose | | Wade Mitchell's dog. |
| | Sarah | Mitchell | Wade Mitchell's mother. |
| | Jacob | | A farmer who works with Wade Mitchell. |
| | | | 1995 |
| | William | | A man Wade Mitchell sought help from. |
| | Beth | | William's Wife. |
| | | | 2007 |
| | Jo | | Ann Mitchell's piano student . |
| | | | 2008-2009 |
| | Bell | | Elizabeth's former co-worker. |
| | | | 2009 |
| | Sonny | | The school janitor. |
| | Justin | | Eliot's friend. |
| | Alyssa | | Eliot's friend. |
| | Julia | | Eliot's new girlfriend. |
| | Allie | | A Social Worker. |
| | Gary | | Eliot's brother. |
| | | | 2012 |
| | Roo | | Wade Mitchell's dog. |
| | Bailey | | June Bailey Roe's daughter. |
| | | | 2024 |
| | Ida | | A little girl in the House of Chamber of Nation's Capitol. |
