1 | Jamie | Chapman | Kerry's friend. Suspected murderer. |
| Kerry | Dowling | Jamie's friend and neighbor. Deceased. |
2 | Marge | Chapman | Jamie's mother. |
3 | Steve | Dowling | Kerry's father. |
| Fran | Dowling | Kerry's mother. |
| Aline | Dowling | Steve and Fran's daughter. Saddle River's guidance counselor. |
| Nancy | Carter | Tony's mother. |
| Sinead | Gilmartin | The man who helped Kerry change her flat tire. |
4 | Jack | Chapman | Marge's husband. |
6 | Michael | Wilson | Homicide Detective. Handles the Dowling Case. |
| Jerome | Weld | Police officer that is first to respond in the Dowling incident. |
| Sharon | Reynolds | Medical examiner. |
7 | Fr. Frank | | Pastor of St. Gabriel Local Parish. aka: Monsignor del Prete. |
| Alan | Crowley | Kerry's possessive boyfriend. Suspected murderer. |
8 | Chris | Kobel | A man trying to get Kerry at the party. |
| Bobby | Whalen | Alan's friend and baseball teammate. |
| Rich | Johnson | Alan's friend and baseball teammate. |
| Stan | Pierce | Alan's friend and baseball teammate. |
10 | Tony | Carter | Jamie's workmate. |
11 | Doug | Crowley | Alan's father. |
| June | Crowley | Alan's mother. |
12 | Grace | | Marge's neighbor. |
13 | Detective | Harsh | Michael's co-detective. |
| Kate | | Kerry's best friend. |
| Ted | Goldberg | Mr. and Mrs. Dowling's friend. A doctor. |
14 | Pat | Tarleton | Aline's boss. Principal. |
16 | Scott | Kimball | Kerry's former Lacrosse coach. |
17 | Valerie | Long | Kerry's friend and teammate. |
18 | Brenda | Niemier | Crowley's housekeeper. Marge's close friend. |
| Curt | Niemier | Brenda's husband. A retired plumber. |
19 | Rick | | Aline's fiance. |
21 | Betsy | Finley | Kerry's friend. |
23 | Don | Brown | Former Coach of the Lacrosse Team. |
25 | Lester | Parker | Alan's well-known defense lawyer. |
30 | Glady | Moore | Alan's waitress. |
| Artie | Schulman | Chief of the Homicide Unit. Assistant prosecutor. |
37 | Paul | Martinez | Kerry Dowling Murder Case Judge. |
40 | David | Willis | Princeton's Director of Admission. |
| Lawrence | Knolls | Princeton's Chief Counsel. |
42 | Barbara | Bagli | A new teacher. Has an interest on Scott. |
44 | Alexis | | Kerry's friend. |
| Annie | | Kerry's friend. |
| Sam | Hines | A young investigator. Mike's assistant. |
46 | Wayne | | Valerie's stepfather. |
51 | Marina | Long | Valerie's mother. |
52 | Greg | Barber | Jamie's attorney. |
54 | Carl | Carter | Tony's father. |
55 | Andy | Nerlino | Wilson's co-detective. |
| Matthew | Koenig | Prosecutor. |
67 | Edward | Dietz | A tow truck driver arrested for using cocaine. Suspected murderer. |
| Ferranda | Brothers | Owner of the truck Edward drives. Auto Salvage company. |
| Sandy | Fitchet | Patrolwoman from Lodi Police Force. |
| Herb | Phillips | Sandy's uncle. |
70 | Gus | Schreiber | Jamie's Acme Manager. |
74 | Angela | Walker | Detective |