| Pro | Connie | Sanborne | Social worker. |
| | Debbie | | Bartender. Aka: Deb. |
| | Tom | Bishop | Retired police chief. |
| | Dick | Bellinger | The dock master and a license process server. |
| | Dottie | Johanson | A widow who ran the local library. |
| | Logan | Hamilton | Matt's fishing buddy. |
| | Matthew | Royal | Retired lawyer. Aka: Matt. |
| 2 | Bill | Lester | The island's current Chief of Police. |
| | Michael | Banion | Manatee County detective. Aka: John. |
| | Dave | Beemer | Longboat Key police officer. |
| 4 | Pearl | | Piano player. |
| 5 | George | Wentworth | Governor of Iowa. |
| | Mary | White | Matt and Logan's friend. |
| | Fred | | Logan's brother. |
| | Molly | O'Sullivan | One of the owners of the bar and restaurant called O'Sullivans'. |
| | Irene | O'Sullivan | One of the owners of the bar and restaurant called O'Sullivans'. |
| | Glenda | | Hostess at the O'Sullivans'. |
| | Elizabeth | Ferguson | State Attorney. |
| 6 | Mavis | Jackson | Elizabeth's secretary. |
| | Bert | Hawkins | Chief Medical Examiner. |
| 7 | Laura | | Matt's ex-wife. |
| | Jason | Clark | Laura's friend. |
| | Jeff | Simmons | Jason Clark's doctor. |
| | Vanessa | Brice | Matt's secretary. |
| 8 | Denny | | Matt's old friend. Aka: K-Dawg. |
| 9 | Bill | Smith | Sam Cox's alias. |
| | Dewey | Clanton | Bar owner. |
| | Jim | Martin | Owns Frisco's bar. Aka: Slim Jim. |
| | Keith | Hastings | Golden Beach Inn's general manager. |
| | Darlene | | Bartender. |
| 10 | Mrs. | Cooper | Northwestern University alumni director. |
| | David | Jarski | Connie's husband. |
| | Lisa | Jarksi | David and Connie's daughter. |
| | Fred | Peed | A lawyer. |
| | Millie | | Former owner of David's house. |
| | Mrs. | Gibbs | David's neighbor. |
| | Vivian | Pickens | One of Golden Joe's prostitutes. |
| 11 | Cynthia | Turner | Grant Settlement House director. |
| | Joseph Dean | Johnson | Drug dealer and pimp. Aka: Golden Joe. |
| | Will | Ledbetter | Vivian's probation officer. |
| | Carol | | Probation and Parole office clerk. |
| | Paulette | Massilon | One of Golden Joe's prostitutes. |
| 12 | Howard | Pickens | Vivian's father. |
| 13 | Dallas | Mahoney | Matt's old friend. |
| | Iva | | Receptionist. |
| | David | | Iva's son. |
| 14 | Samuel | Cox | Vice President of Rundel Enterprises. Aka: Sam. |
| 15 | Hale | Rundel | President of Rundel Enterprises. |
| | Maria | Cox | Sam's wife. Aka: Maria Domingo. |
| | Donald | Jones | Resident agent for service of process. |
| | John | James | One of Rundel's fake investors. |
| | Sally | | Manager at Gulf Breakers. |
| 16 | Dave | Tuten | Gulfview sheriff. |
| | John | Noblin | John James's stepson. |
| | Bud | Dubose | Anne's brother. |
| | Anne | Dubose | Real estate lawyer. |
| 18 | Marge | | Bud's wife. |
| | Jimmy | Greene | Matt's old friend. |
| | Paul | Jensen | Greene's chief pilot. |
| 20 | Mandy | | Anne's friend. |
| | Joachin | Jiminez | Matt's friend. Aka: J.J. |
| | Oscar | Jimenez | J.J.'s father. |
| | Carmen | | J.J.'s mother. |
| | Jorge | | Maria's father. |
| 21 | Carl | Merritt | Anne's detective friend in Miami. |
| | Ryan | Mallard | Homicide detective. |
| | John | Allred | One of Matt's
acquaintances. |
| 22 | | | Longboat Observer - local newspaper |
| 25 | T. Johnson | O'Reilly | Court judge. |
| | Bonnie | Moore | Court custodian. |
| | Richard | Wightman | Elizabeth's assistant. |
| 28 | Hernando | Domingo | Maria's eldest brother. |
| 30 | Miles | Leavitt | Chicago Police lieutenant. |
