| Logan |
Anders | Jeanie's boyfriend |
| Noah |
Barnett | Owner of a fishing tour company in Dream Harbour. Aka: Noah James Barnett |
| Melinda |
Church | Current owner of the Cinnamon Bun Bookstore |
| Bennett |
Ellis | Jeanie's brother. Aka: Ben |
| Dorothy |
Ellis | Jeanie's aunt. Aka: Dot |
| Jeanie |
Ellis | Owner of the Pumpkin Spice Café |
| Hazel |
Kelly | Protagonist; runs the Cinnamon Bun Bookstore |
| Pete |
Kelly | Hazel's father; the town's mayor |
| Kira |
North | New resident in town |
| Amir |
Sharma | Café regular |
| Rico |
Stephen | Café regular |
| Macaulay |
Sullivan | Pub owner. Aka: Mac |
| Alex |
| One of Hazel's employees |
| Amber |
| One of Mac's servers |
| Andy |
| Schoolteacher |
| Annie |
| Owner of Sugar Plum Bakery; Hazel's friend |
| Casper |
| Jeanie's cat |
| Cece |
| Noah's niece |
| Cliff |
| Bar customer |
| Crystal |
| One of Jeanie's friends |
| Danny |
| One of Mac's employees |
| Diego |
| One of Hazel's mother's dogs |
| Estelle |
| Logan's grandmother |
| Frank |
| Husband of Hazel's father |
| Frida |
| One of Hazel's mother's dogs |
| George |
| Baker |
| Ginger |
| Noah's boat |
| Henry |
| Logan's grandfather |
| Isaac |
| One of Mac's servers |
| Isabel |
| One of Jeanie's book club friends |
| Ivy |
| Noah's niece |
| Jacob |
| Book club member |
| Jane |
| Isabel's daughter |
| Joel |
| Hazel's ex-boyfriend |
| Kaori |
| One of Jeanie's book club friends |
| Kristen |
| Noah's sister |
| Logan |
| Noah's friend; Jeanie's boyfriend |
| Lyndsay |
| One of Hazel's employees |
| Marc |
| Isabel's father |
| Maribel |
| New Dream Harbour neighbor |
| Marty |
| Bar customer |
| Michael |
| Noah's new nephew |
| Mindy |
| Deputy mayor |
| Norman |
| Dot's right-hand man |
| Patrick |
| Rachel's husband |
| Rachel |
| Noah's sister; Cece's mother |
| Tammy |
| One of Hazel's friends |
| Trent |
| Annie's new friend |
