| Sheila |
Berg | Lewis County mental health doctor. |
| Evelyn |
Brodie | Samantha's mother. |
| Samantha |
Brodie | One of the Hatchet Killer's victims. |
| Jim |
Burns | Skidder operator. |
| Nettie |
Crane | Long-time Joy resident. |
| James |
Dean | One of Joey's football players. |
| Mrs. |
Dietrich | Joey's school principal. |
| Leeza |
Dixon | Former district attorney. |
| Jack |
Foley | Lewis County sheriff. |
| Steve |
Green | Kootenai Forest ranger. |
| Callan |
Grey | Kerry's grandfather. |
| Kerry |
Grey-Yates | Wife of an accused serial killer. |
| Chet |
Hanson | Lewis County deputy coroner. |
| Ty |
Hendricks | Convicted addict. |
| Trevor |
Hunt | Owner and pilot of Big Bear Air. |
| Lynn |
Jones | Wyatt's wife. |
| Wyatt |
Jones | Kerry's ex-boyfriend. |
| Bob |
Kenny | Gold Bar Casino owner. |
| Emily |
Lynn | One of the Hatchet Killer's victims. |
| Pony |
Malloy | Local tattoo artist. |
| Abby |
Marshal | One of the Hatchet Killer's victims. |
| Lindsey |
Marshal | Sister of the third victim. |
| Amber |
Miller | Police front desk and dispatcher. |
| Adam |
Nash | Protagonist, Kerry's parole officer. |
| Miranda |
Nash | Adam's wife. |
| Aiden |
Peterson | Joey's classmate. |
| Trish |
Peterson | Aiden's mother. |
| Lana |
Reece | Abby's friend. |
| Braxton |
Ryan | President of the Hatchet Club. Aka: Brax. |
| Rachel |
Santini | Certified counselor, Hatchet Club member. |
| Lance |
Schulz | The dog handler. |
| Robert |
Shackly | Host of "Unsolved Murders". |
| Mrs. |
Sills | Joey's teacher. |
| Jay |
Stacker | Lucas's neighbor. |
| Allison |
Turner | Missing person. |
| Angela |
Turner | Allison's mother. |
| Chrissie |
VanElst | Kerry's old classmate. |
| Adam |
Walsh | The original host's son of America's Most Wanted. |
| David |
Wheeler | New reporter. |
| Danielle |
White Elk | Kerry's best friend. |
| Robin |
Williams | American actor mentioned. |
| Joey |
Yates | Kerry and Lucas's child. |
| Lucas |
Yates | Kerry's husband, suspected serial killer. Aka: The Hatchet Killer. |
| Al |
| The man that Lucas saved. |
| Bird |
| One of Adam's new colleagues. |
| Elvis |
| One of Joey's football players. |
| Marco |
| Adam's neighbor. |
| Marilyn |
| One of Joey's football players. |
| McCulley |
| One of Adam's new colleagues. |
| Rachel |
| Marco's wife. |
| Ryker |
| Lance's K9. |
| Sam |
| Wyatt's uncle. |
