| Max |
Barnes | Brooke's ex-boyfriend |
| Liam |
Davenport | Noah's business partner and best friend |
| Oakley |
Davenport | Liam's wife |
| Priya |
Kapoor Wimberly | Noah's first wife. Aka: Riya |
| Detective |
Martinez | Detective assigned to the case |
| Ricardo |
Martinez | Penn's ex-boyfriend, private investigator |
| Sage |
Miller | Brooke's new babysitter |
| Abella Penelope |
Montgomery | Brooke's baby daughter |
| Brooke |
Montgomery | Protagonist and narrator |
| William |
Shakespeare | Famous playwright |
| Penelope |
Simms | Brooke's best friend from New York. Aka: Penny, Penn |
| Parker |
Sully | Noah's old friend, gynecologist |
| Serena |
Sully | Parker's wife |
| Noah |
Wimberly | Richest surgeon in Laguna Beach, Brooke's fiancée |
| Ivy |
Winters | The wedding planner |
| Cinderella |
| Fairytale character |
| Jessica |
| Postpartum nurse |
| Melinda |
| Doctor, Brooke's former client |
| Mindy |
| Noah's main housekeeper |
