| Dr. |
Boyd | Sheriff Ryan's physician |
| Carissa |
Brooks | Bob's hairdresser |
| George |
Carrigan | Carissa's ex-partner |
| Officer |
Clark | Desk officer |
| Jackie |
Clarke | Woman killed by Stevens |
| Anne |
Davis | Office manager and Sarah's close friend |
| Jesse |
Hook | Man who stalked Kelly |
| Stacy |
Howard | Young woman with ties to Bob Miller |
| Marcus |
Hudson | Current sheriff; noble and honest |
| Deputy |
Lane | Sheriff's deputy |
| Sergeant |
Lantz | Police officer |
| Robert |
Miller | Sarah's ex-husband. Aka: Bob |
| Sarah |
Morgan | High-powered criminal defense attorney and the protagonist |
| Summer |
Morgan | Sarah and Bob's daughter |
| Adam |
Morgan | Sarah's first husband |
| Deputy |
Morrow | Sheriff's deputy |
| Lieutenant |
Nagel | Police officer |
| Pam |
Olson | Chief deputy and Hudson's partner |
| Alejandro |
Perez | Sarah's client; aka Alex |
| Tim |
Redding | Victim of a hit-and-run |
| Eleanor |
Rumple | Sarah's former mother-in-law |
| Ryan |
Stevens | Former sheriff |
| Kelly |
Summers | Adam's mistress; aka Jenna Way |
| Scott |
Summers | Kelly's husband |
| Taylor |
Swift | American singer-songwriter |
| Deena |
Walsh | Stacy's roommate |
| Gretchen |
Waters | Reporter covering the case |
| Brad |
Watson | Bob's lawyer and longtime friend |
| Caroline |
Wood | Interviewer one year later |
| Candace |
| Kent's admin |
| Corey |
| DC lobbyist |
| Courtney |
| Summer's friend |
| Greg |
| Bob's brother |
| Jamie |
| Anne's partner |
| Jess |
| Sarah's lawyer |
| Kent |
| Bob Miller's boss |
| Marcy |
| Sheriff Hudson's admin assistant |
| Natalie |
| Receptionist at the Morgan Foundation |
| Roger |
| Security guard |