| Logan |
Anders | Produce deliveryman |
| Nancy |
Drew | Fictional detective referenced in dialogue |
| Bennett |
Ellis | Jeanie's brother. Aka: Ben |
| Dorothy |
Ellis | Jeanie's aunt; founder of the Pumpkin Spice Café. Aka: Aunt Dot |
| Jeanie |
Ellis | New owner of the Pumpkin Spice Café |
| Hazel |
Kelly | Bookstore owner |
| Pete |
Kelly | Mayor; Hazel's father |
| Barbara |
Sanders | Realtor. Aka: Barb |
| Harry |
Styles | Logan's alpaca |
| Macaulay |
Sullivan | Owner of the pub next to the café. Aka: Mac |
| Mindy |
Walsh | Deputy mayor; former principal |
| Annie |
| Owner of Sugar Plum Bakery |
| Casper |
| Stray cat found by Jeanie and Logan |
| Crystal |
| Longtime café employee |
| Dylan |
| One of Nana's goats |
| Emily |
| Jeanie's colleague and roommate |
| Estelle |
| Logan's grandmother. Aka: Nana |
| George |
| Employee at the bakery |
| Greg |
| Pet store owner |
| Isabel |
| Member of the book club |
| Jacob |
| Isabel's son; Mateo's brother |
| Joe |
| Café employee |
| Kaori |
| Book club leader; Jeanie's new friend |
| Leroy |
| Café regular |
| Linda |
| Nancy's wife |
| Lucy |
| Logan's ex-girlfriend |
| Marley |
| One of Nana's goats |
| Marvin |
| Jeanie's former boss |
| Mateo |
| Isabel's baby |
| Nancy |
| Retired café regular |
| Noah |
| Captain of the SS Ginger; Logan's best friend |
| Norman |
| Dorothy's right-hand man |
| Shawn |
| Greg's co-owner |
| Tammy |
| Tim's wife |
| Tim |
| Café regular |
