| Eve |
Bennett | Protagonist |
| Nathaniel |
Bennett | Eve Bennett's husband; the school's star teacher. Aka: Nate |
| Mrs. |
Cavanaugh | Addie's gym teacher |
| Bryce |
Evans | An A-plus student |
| Mr. |
Higgins | School principal |
| Hudson |
Jankowski | Kenzie Montgomery's boyfriend; the new star quarterback |
| Kyle |
Lewis | Addie's classmate |
| Kenzie |
Montgomery | Most popular student |
| Mary |
Pickering | Senior student. Aka: Lotus |
| Edgar Allan |
Poe | Famous American poet and writer |
| Elvis |
Presley | Famous American musician and actor |
| Adeline |
Severson | Troubled junior student. Aka: Addie |
| Detective |
Sprague | Lead detective on the case |
| Arthur |
Tuttle | Beloved math teacher. Aka: Art |
| Marsha |
Tuttle | Arthur Tuttle's wife |
| Connor |
| Shelby's son |
| Ella |
| Girl who was kind to Addie |
| Hailey |
| French teacher |
| Jasmine |
| One of Eve's students |
| Jay |
| Eve's secret lover |
| Justin |
| Shelby's husband |
| Shelby |
| Fellow teacher and Eve's friend |
