| Professor |
Brimley | Kyra Munin-Winthrop's boss |
| E. E. |
Cummings | American poet and author |
| Aiden |
Finlay | Jacob Winthrop's friend |
| Dr. |
Gateman | Obstetrician-gynecologist treating Kyra |
| Audrey |
Hepburn | Classic Hollywood actress and humanitarian |
| Doug |
Ingram | Artist who mistakes Kyra for someone else |
| Angelina |
Jolie | American actress and humanitarian |
| Sylvia |
LaCrosse | Clinical social worker assisting Kyra |
| Tom |
Michaelson | First responder at Fire District 12 |
| Kyra |
Munin-Winthrop | Narrator and protagonist who has lost her memory |
| Eliza |
Penny | Fortune teller; owner of Mystic Thyme |
| Nancy |
Phelps | Kyra Munin-Winthrop's neighbor and friend |
| Van |
Phelps | Nancy Phelps's husband |
| Brad |
Pitt | American actor and film producer |
| Rachel |
Spignola | Woman Kyra encounters at the store |
| Linny |
Strabeck | Kyra Munin-Winthrop's best friend |
| Mrs. |
Waverly | Owner of Mystic Cove Bed and Breakfast |
| Jacob |
Winthrop | Kyra Munin-Winthrop's husband |
| Malinda |
Winthrop | Woman depicted in the mysterious painting |
| Earl |
| Firefighter |
| Frances |
| Local librarian |
| Theo |
| Kyra Munin-Winthrop's uncle |
