| Gunner |
Banks | Police officer; Casey's friend |
| Annabelle |
Chapman | Mayor's wife; victim |
| Scarlet |
Evans | Kidnapped girl |
| Mason |
Hill | Boy with autism |
| Genevieve |
Hill | Mason's mother; social media influencer |
| John |
Hill | Genevieve's husband; Mason's father |
| Savannah |
Hill | Genevieve's daughter; Mason's sister |
| William |
Jones | Landscape contractor |
| Detective |
Layne | Lead detective on Annabelle's case |
| Shelby |
Richardson | Genevieve's colleague |
| Patrisha |
Roberts | Agent at Family Service Division of Alabama Human Resource. Aka: Trish |
| Marsha |
Seale | Casey's acquaintance |
| Owen |
Taylor | Casey's former client; has delayed speech |
| Mrs. |
Taylor | Owen's mother |
| Donald |
Trump | Current U.S. President |
| Casey |
Walker | Protagonist |
| Harper |
Walker | Casey's daughter; has autism |
| Dr. Lee |
Winslow | Developmental pediatric specialist |
| Billy |
| One of Casey's students |
| Blanche |
| Mason's foster mother |
| Brett |
| Savannah's boyfriend |
| Davis |
| Casey's ex-boyfriend |
| Earl |
| One of the villagers |
| Kelly |
| Harper's assistant teacher |
| Monster |
| The suspect |
| Nadine |
| One of the villagers |
| Phoebe |
| Casey's acquiantance. |
| Renetta |
| Genevieve's interviewer |
| Richard |
| Genevieve's lawyer |
| Sam |
| Staff at juvenile center |
| Simon |
| The man Genevieve hired to fake attack Annabelle |
| Stephen |
| Richard's client |
| Tessa |
| One of the witnesses |
