| Elsabeth |
Coletto | Luca and Merritt's daughter. Aka: Elsie |
| Everett |
Coletto | Luca's paternal grandfather |
| Everett John |
Coletto | Luca and Merritt's son |
| Luca |
Coletto | Lydia's husband |
| Lydia |
Coletto | Luca's first wife; missing |
| Merritt |
Coletto | Luca's second wife |
| Amber |
Dubois | Delphine's daughter |
| Delphine |
Dubois | Owner of the Blessed Alchemist |
| Nolan |
Rhinehart | Detective who helps Lydia |
| Adair |
| Merritt's sister |
| Annette |
| Elsie's nanny |
| Astrid |
| The hostess at Luca's restaurant |
| Catherine |
| Merritt's nurse |
| Gloria |
| Delphine's monthly visitor |
| Jolie |
| Restaurant server |
| Levi |
| Male server |
| Powder |
| Delphine's cat |
| The Monster |
| The man who kidnaps Lydia |
