| Ted |
Bundy | American serial killer. |
| Detective |
Eubanks | Lead detective on Tilly's case. |
| Detective |
Harrison | Detective Eubanks's partner. |
| Sarah |
Hill | The new owner of the cabin. |
| Cassie |
Lowe | Lenora's sister. |
| Lenora |
Lowe | Cassie's agoraphobic identical twin. |
| Beatrice |
Martin | A missing woman. |
| Karen |
Meadows | Tilly's mother. |
| Matilda Nicole |
Meadows | The girl Cassie met in the woods; deceased. Aka: Tilly. |
| Robert |
Meadows | Tilly's father. Aka: Rob. |
| Mrs. |
Rhodes | Cassie's neighbor. |
| Pastor |
Smith | The town reverend. |
| Martha |
Stewart | American businesswoman and television personality. |
| Joan |
Wellesley | The prettiest and richest girl in the school. |
| Kate |
Wellesley | Joan's sister; deceased. |
| Emily |
Wells | Sandra's sister. |
| Sandra |
Wells | A missing woman; Sarah Hill's real identity. |
| Aswell |
| Mrs. Rhodes's pet. |
| Daphne |
| Lenora's therapist. |
| Jamar |
| One of Lenora's classmates. |
| Josh |
| Beatrice's boyfriend. |
| Lisa |
| Cassie and Lenora's aunt. |
| Mark |
| Wayne's nephew. |
| Monica |
| Emily's friend. |
| Parker |
| Cassie's lover. |
| Peter |
| One of Lenora's classmates. |
| Toby |
| Lenora's former neighbor. |
| Wayne |
| A drunkard who owns the cabin. |
