| Pro | Regina | Torrance | Live in the hills above Snow Creek. Aka: Reggie. |
| | Amy | | Regina's wife. |
| 1 | Megan | Carpenter | A detective. |
| | Ruth | Turner | A complainant about her missing sister. |
| | Ida | Wheaton | Ruth Turner's sister. |
| | Merritt | Wheaton | Ida's husband. |
| | Sarah | | Ida's daughter. |
| | Joshua | | Ida's son. |
| | Tony | Gray | A sheriff. |
| 2 | Hayden | | Megan's brother. |
| 5 | Karen | Albright | A psychologist. |
| | Maria | | Megan's roommate. |
| | Rylee | | Megan's forgotten name. |
| 8 | Dante | York | A future cryptozoologist. |
| | Maddie | Cohen | Dante York's off-and-on girlfriend. |
| | Sam | Otis | A sawyer from Puget Logging Co. |
| 9 | Larry | Larsen | A coroner. |
| 10 | Jared | | A caretaker of animals. |
| 11 | Dr. | Andrade | A pathologist. |
| 13 | Ted | Bundy | American serial killer. |
| | Gary | Ridgway | American serial killer. |
| 14 | Princess Angeline | | Chief Seattle's daughter. |
| 15 | Maxine | Jacobson | One of the Wheaton's neighbors. |
| 16 | Chad | | One who worked at sheriff's office. |
| | Nan | | One who worked at sheriff's office. |
| 19 | Earl | Jacobson | Maxine's husband. |
| | Daniel | Anderson | One of the Wheaton's neighbors. Aka: Dan. |
| 20 | Dan | Miller | One of the Wheaton's neighbors. |
| 21 | William J. | Walters | An army enlistee. |
| | Ginger | Walters | William's next of kin. |
| | Ginger | Rhode | Rylee's aunt. |
| | Alex Richard | Rader | A serial killer. |
| | Shannon | Blume | One of the girls from Seattle-Tacoma who was murdered. |
| | Megan | Moriarty | One of the girls from Seattle-Tacoma who was murdered. |
| | Leanne | Delmont | One of the girls from Seattle-Tacoma who was murdered. |
| 22 | Bernadine | Chesterfield | A social worker and victims advocate. Aka: Bernie. |
| | Davis | | One of Megan's deputies. |
| | Copsey | | One of Megan's deputies. |
| 24 | Mindy Scott | Newson | A crime scene tech. |
| | Eve | | Ruth Turner's daughter. |
| 25 | Dr. | Phil | American television personality, author and host. |
| | Courtney | | Real name of Rylee's mother. |
| 27 | Jake | Jackson | A news reporter. |
| 32 | Laurna | Volkman | Carrie's sister. |
| | Hudson | | Laurna's brother-in-law. |
| | Carrie | | Hudson's wife |
| | Ellie | Burbank | Laurna's niece. |
| | Hans | | Laurna's husband. |
| 33 | Justin | Bieber | Canadian singer-songwriter. |
| | Drake | | Canadian rapper, singer, songwriter, actor. |
| | Halsey | | American singer, songwriter, and activist. |
| | Tyra | Whitcomb | Ellie's best friend. |
| | Troy | Whitcomb | Tyra's father. |
| 34 | Chantelle | Potter | Carrie's neighbor and friend. |
| | Susan | Whitcomb | Troy's wife. |
| 36 | Mr. | Potter | Chantelle's husband. |
| | Matt | | Chantelle's son. |
| | Carl | Tanzler | Radiologic technologists. |
| | Elena Milagro | de Hoyos | Carl Tanzler's patient. |
| 38 | Marley | Yang | Lab tech supervisor. |
| 43 | Clifton | Scott | Ellie's lawyer. |
| | Paul | Singer | School head administrator. |
| 44 | Becky | Webster | A teacher. |
| 45 | Miss Cathy | | School secretary. |
| 50 | Maren | Morris | American singer, songwriter, and record producer. |
