| Pro | Alice | Mullin | Sam's great-great grandmother. Owner: Mullin's Secret Recipe. |
| | Leo | Mullin | Alice's husband. |
| | Mac | | Alice's dog. |
| | | | Part 1 |
| 1 | Sam | Nelson | Protagonist. |
| | Willo | Beck | Sam's grandma. Aka: Grandma Willo, Mom. |
| | Angelo | Morelli | Sam's lover. Aka: Jersey. |
| | Trish | | Sam's friend. Pastry chef head. |
| | Chef | Dimples | The owner of Dimples Bakery. Sam's boss. Aka: Dwight Lilliputh. |
| | Suzette | | A young dishwasher at Dimples Bakery. |
| 2 | Gordon | Beck | Sam's grandfather. Willo's husband. |
| | Connor | | Sam's ex-boyfriend. |
| | Deana | Nelson | Sam's mother. |
| | Aaron | Nelson | Sam's brother. |
| | Doris | | Willo and Gordon's dog. |
| | | | Part 2 |
| 4 | Lily | | Sam's roommate. |
| | Mario | Batali | A famous chef. |
| | Jimmy | Jenkins | The boy who stole Sam's bike. |
| | | | Part 3 |
| 8 | Fred | | Willo's boyfriend. |
| | Joseph | Smith | The founder of Latter Day Saint. |
| | James | Strang | Joseph's
successor. |
| | Heraclitus | | A Greek Philosopher. |
| | Elizabeth | | Clement's wife. |
| | Clement | | The Lighthouse keeper. |
| | | | Part 4 |
| 11 | Madge | Beck | Willo's mother. |
| | Wilbur | Beck | Willo's father. |
| | Babe | | Madge and Wilbur's yellow
Labrador. |
| | | | Part 5 |
| 14 | Amanda | | The girl who was serving apple cider. |
| 15 | Gary | Nelson | Sam's father. |
| 16 | Peachy | | Willo and Gordon's dog. |
| | Mr. Essex | | Michigan University graduate. Owner of Essex Engineering. |
| | | | Part 7 |
| 18 | Donna | Cupertino | The woman who worked at the pie pantry. |
| | Debbie | Cupertino | The woman who worked at the pie pantry. |
| | Dede | Cupertino | The woman who worked at the pie pantry. |
| | Julia | Child | An American Chef. |
| | | | Part 8 |
| 21 | Sylvia | | Willo's friend. |
| | | | Part 10 |
| 27 | Collette | | Trish's boss. |
| | | | Part 11 |
| 31 | Dorothy | | Sam's acquaintance. |
| 33 | Sandra | Lee | A Baker. |
| 34 | Jackson | | The chubby little boy. |
| | Audrey | Tautou | The French actress. |
| Epi | Alice | | Sam's granddaughter. |
| | John | | Alice's husband. |
