DISCUSSION QUESTIONS The Pull of the Stars |
1. How has the current pandemic changed the way you approach The Pull of
the Stars? What similarities do you see between the pandemic in the
novel and the one we’re living through now? What details are different?
2. Do you think that people will be more or less likely to read this
novel now in light of what is going on? Do you think that your own
opinion of the novel is influenced by your response to the day-to-day
realities of living amidst COVID-19?
3. World War I is reaching its end and Julia’s home country, Ireland, is
in the midst of political turmoil regarding Home Rule. How does this
total lack of normalcy affect Julia and the other characters? Do you
think that the novel does a good job of balancing these various world
events?
4. Discuss the intersections where the war, the influenza, and the civil
unrest all meet: a. How do the crises allow Julia to operate differently
than she might have in a more normal era? b. Would the novel have
unfolded in the same way if the influenza had been an isolated incident,
and Julia and the others did not have to deal with the war or the
heightened Irish politics? How might it have changed?
5. Throughout the novel, Julia clashes with various members of the
church, particularly Sister Luke. Does The Pull of the Stars have a
deliberate anti-religion message? Is it a condemnation of human rights
abuses perpetrated by those who claim to be against them? a. One
particularly memorable offense detailed is when Bridie tells Julia about
the priest who thought it improper to leave teenaged daughters with a
widowed father and Julia balks at the depravity and hypocrisy of such a
statement coming from a priest: “For a priest to make such a
comment—somehow both prudish and filthyminded…” (182). Why do you think
Donoghue included details like this?
6. Discuss Groyne as a character. How much sympathy are we meant to feel
for him? Are we meant to feel as Julia does, that he is an unlikeable
chauvinist? Or should we, like Bridie, look deeper to see the tragedies
that lie beneath the surface?
7. What do you make of Julia’s relationship with Bridie? How do the two
of them even each other out? a. Consider the things that Julia is able
to teach Bridie and the things that she entirely overlooks until Bridie
points them out to her. Would their relationship have flourished in
other circumstances? Would their relationship have even been possible in
other circumstances? The Pull of the Stars by Emma Donoghue Discussion
Questions Taken from: https://funfandomblog.wordpress.com/ | 2
8. Julia delivers many babies over the course of the novel, and she gets
every single possible combination. Delia Garrett’s baby dies, but she
lives. Both Ita Noonan and her child die. Both Mary O’Rahilly and her
baby live. Honor White dies, but her baby lives. Why is it important to
see this full spectrum of life and death? What do you make of the fact
that, before Julia is placed in charge of the ward, not a single woman
with influenza had gone into labor?
9. Discuss Bridie as a character. Were you surprised to learn about her
abusive upbringing, or did you see the clues before Julia did? Why do
you think that author Emma Donoghue chose to reveal so much of Bridie’s
character towards the end of the novel instead of spreading it out
throughout? a. What do you think of Bridie’s lie about previously having
the grippe? Was it heroic, particularly with regards to the fear most
other characters display, or was it stupid? Was it dishonest for Bridie
to lie to get into the room? Should she have told the truth and given
Julia the chance to have an assistant who could be with her long-term?
Did you like Bridie? How surprised were you by her sudden death? What
foreshadowing—if any—did you pick up on?
10. Discuss the title. Julia tells us that the word influenza means “the
influence of the stars. Medieval Italians thought the illness proved
that the heavens were governing their fates, that people were quite
literally star-crossed” (147). a. Are mortals like Julia defenseless
against the push and pull of fate, of a force as powerful as the
influenza? Consider her later statement that “I’d never believed the
future was inscribed for each of us the day we were born. If anything
was written in the stars, it was we who joined those dots, and our lives
were the writing” (244). b. Do Julia, Bridie, and the others ultimately
submit to the pull of the stars, or do they escape their fate? Also
discuss the idea of the influenza as a living entity. * Some questions from Westfargond. |
Home l About Us l Features l Contact Us l Share l Submit Book |