| 1 | Hope | Miller | Lindsay's friend. Missing. Aka: Tara King. |
| | Lindsay | Kelly | Hope's best friend. A lawyer. |
| | Evan | Hunter | An independent realtor. Hope's boss. |
| | Stan | Stansfield | Owner of the house that is being sold. |
| | Robin | Stansfield | Stan's wife. |
| 2 | Tony | Beckett | Hope's landlord. |
| | Grace | Beckett | Tony's wife. |
| | Max | Beckett | Tony and Grace's son. |
| | Bobby | Beckett | Tony and Grace's son. |
| | Miriam | | Lindsay's stepmother. Aka: Karen Henderson. |
| | Scott | Parker | Lindsay's boyfriend. |
| | Nora | | Scott's daughter. |
| 3 | Ellie | Hatcher | The NYPD detective. |
| | Max | | Ellie's lover. A district attorney. |
| | Jess | Hatcher | Ellie's brother. |
| 6 | Carter | Decker | A cop. Robin's neighbor and friend. |
| 11 | William | Summer | The College Hill Strangler. A serial killer. |
| | Janice | Beale | Murdered. |
| | Jerry | Hatcher | The detective in charge of the College Hill Strangler investigation. Ellie's father. |
| | Catherine | Gondelman | The cottage owner. |
| 12 | J.J | Rogan | Ellie's partner. |
| | Hank | | Ellie's neighbor. |
| | Edna | | Hank's wife. |
| 14 | Lisa | Robbins | A police officer. |
| | Alex | Lopez | Murdered. |
| 15 | Steve | Thompson | Jerry's former partner. |
| | Leo | | The bar manager. |
| 16 | Rebecca | | Hope's therapist. |
| 18 | Harvy | O'Brien | A T.V. reporter. |
| | Chris | | A reputable journalist. |
| | Dr. Loretta | Mason | The deputy chief. |
| | Jocelyn | Hodge | Alex's girlfriend. |
| 19 | Frank | Garner | The Reel Deal Fishing owner. |
| 23 | Ed | Carpenter | Lindsay's client. |
| | Katy | Barnes | The woman who posted on the camp page about past abuse. |
| | Carl | Walsh | Hope's ex-boyfriend. |
| 24 | Marcia | | The news reporter. |
| | Reggie | | Marcia's colleague. |
| 26 | Mrs. | Streeter | A thrift shop owner. |
| | Bob | Taylor | The man who brought the rug. |
| | Melanie | Locke | Richard's widow. |
| 28 | Holly | Gunther | Alex's co-campers. |
| | Emilia | Lopez | Alex's alleged sister. |
| | Richard | Mullaney | A noted attorney and philanthropist. Murdered. |
| 30 | Kevin | Mitchell | A bartender. |
| 32 | Catherine | Harper | The judge. |
| | Mike | Nunzio | The lawyer at the prosecution table. |
| 34 | TC | Atkinson | The girl that Jess dated. |
| 36 | Sophie | | Melanie and Richard's daughter. |
| 39 | Laura | King | Hope's mother. |
| 40 | Roberta | Hatcher | Elise and Jess's mother. |
| 41 | Melissa | | Hope's therapist. |
