| Carl D. | Agostino | San Diego police sergeant. |
| Lucy | Chen | Maeve's acquaintance. |
| Cooper | Clay | One of the protagonists. Baseball star. |
| Jules | Crandall | Phoebe's friend. Nate's admirer. |
| Sandeep | Ghai | Eli's worker. |
| Dr. | Guitterez | Maeve's oncologist. |
| Principal | Gupta | The school Principal. |
| Intense | Guy | The mysterious man looking for Phoebe. |
| Monica | Hill | One of the Junior girls. |
| Jared | Jackson | Ray's brother. Thief. |
| Ray | Jackson | Police who was detained for blackmailing and framing a teenaged girl for drug possession. |
| Mrs. | Kaplan | Maeve's teacher. |
| Simon | Kelleher | Deceased. The Mayor's son. |
| Eli | Kleinfelter | Ashton's fiancé. |
| Emma | Lawton | Phoebe's sister. |
| Owen | Lawton | Phoebe's brother. |
| Phoebe | Lawton | Café Contigo waitress. One of the narrators. |
| Nate | Macauley | One of the protagonists. Drug mole. |
| Martin | McCoy | Emma's lawyer. |
| Detective | Mendoza | Bayview police detective. |
| Knox | Meyers | Maeve's boyfriend. One of the narrators. |
| Sean | Murdock | Jules's student. |
| Kiersten | Myers | Knox's sister. |
| Evan | Neiman | Bronwyn's ex boyfriend. |
| Bethany | Okonjo | Law student. |
| Adelaide | Prentiss | One of the protagonists. AKA: Addy. |
| Ashton | Prentiss | Addy's older sister. |
| Dax | Reaper | The most ruthless bounty hunter. |
| Jake | Riordan | Deceased. Addy's ex boyfriend. |
| Maeve | Rojas | Bronwyn's sister. One of the narrators. |
| Liz | Rosen | News reporter. |
| Coach | Ruffalo | Cooper's baseball coach. |
| Chase | Russo | Lucy's boyfriend. |
| Luis | Santos | Cooper's best friend. |
| Matthias | Schroeder | Maeve's schoolmate. |
| Janae | Vargas | Simon's best friend. |
| Brandon | Weber | Football player. Phoebe's boyfriend. |
| Lance | Weber | Brandon's father. |
| Bayview2020 | | Online forum member. |
| Bronwyn Rojas | | Maeve's sister. Nate's girlfriend. |
| Darkestmind | | Online forum member. |
| Derek | | Emma's boyfriend. |
| Fritz | | Knox's dog. |
| Gillian | | Emma's friend. |
| Ita | | Bronwyn's grandparent. |
| Ito | | Bronwyn's grandparent. |
| Kris | | Cooper's boyfriend. |
| Manny | | Luis's brother. |
