| 1 | Lani | Whitehorse | The woman who was trapped at the bottom of the lake. |
| | Angelique Lovelie | Badeau | Missing. AKA: Angel, Lili. |
| | Frankie | Elkin | Protagonist. |
| | Paul | | Frankie's boyfriend. |
| 2 | Stoney | | A bar owner. |
| | Bill | | Frankie's friend. |
| | Piper | | Stoney's cat. |
| 3 | Guerline | Violette | Angelique's aunt. |
| | Emmanuel | Badeau | Angelique's brother. |
| | Kyra | | Angelique's close friend. |
| | Marjorlie | | Angelique's close friend. |
| 4 | Viv | | Frankie's workmate. |
| 5 | Richard | O'Shaughnessy | The community liaison. |
| | Gwynne Margaret | Andal | One of the missing girls that Frankie found. |
| | Peggy Struzezki | Griffith | One of the missing girls that Frankie found. |
| | Dan | Lotham | The lead detective in Angelique's case. |
| 8 | Albert | | Viv's brother. |
| 9 | Charlie | | The army veteran. A support group member. |
| | Arnold | | The support group leader. |
| | Ariel | | Charlie's companion. |
| 11 | Dr. | Cappa | Angelique's teacher. |
| | Andrew | Jackson | The President. |
| 12 | Tamara | Levesque | Angelique's fake ID. |
| 14 | Camille | | Stoney's wife. |
| | Jerome | | Stoney's son. Deceased. |
| 15 | Charadee | | The Dunkin Donut manager. |
| | Dutch | | The man who runs an after-school program. |
| | Antoine | | Dutch's colleague. |
| | Frederic | Lagudu | Ms. Violette's friend. The Executive Director of the Rec Center. |
| | Lillian | | The activity director. |
| 16 | Agent | Ford | Lotham's colleague. |
| | Livia | Samdi | Missing. |
| 18 | Roseline | Samdi | Livia's mother. |
| 19 | Johnson | Samdi | Livia's older brother. AKA: JJ. |
| 21 | Mr. | Riddenscail | Livia's
AutoCAD teacher. |
| | Mrs. | Jones | The school's guidance counselor. |
| 26 | DommyJ | | Marjorlie's ex-boyfriend. |
| 28 | Michael | Duarde | One of Stoney's regulars. |
| 32 | Deke | Alarie | JJ and Livia's half-brother. |
| 35 | Amy | | The girl that Paul really loved. |
| 37 | Holden | | Frederic and Dutch's colleague. |
