| 1 | Lucy |
Chase | Narrator |
| | Jerry |
Howell | Lucy's boss |
| | Chelsea |
| Jerry and Raymond's assistant |
| 2 | Savannah |
Harper | Murdered. Aka: Savvy |
| | Ben |
Owens | Podcaster |
| | Nathan |
| Lucy's boyfriend |
| | Brewster |
| Nathan's dog, a yellow lab |
| | Maya |
Harper | Savvy's younger sister |
| 3 | Grandma |
| Birthday party coming up |
| 4 | Norma |
| Front desk at hotel |
| 5 | Gil |
Bradford | Discovered Body |
| 6 | Billy Jack |
| Saw Lucy walking |
| | Ivy |
Harper | Savannah's mother |
| | Keaton |
Harper | Savvy's oldest sibling |
| | Jerome |
Harper | Savannah's father |
| | Matt |
Gardner | Lucy's rich husband |
| 7 | Aubrey |
Vargas | Lucy's agent |
| | Eva |
Knightley | Lucy's online media name |
| | Amber |
Hutton | Reader |
| | Erica |
Burton | Reader |
| | Clayton |
| Story character |
| | Poppy |
| Story character |
| | Jan |
| Church receptionist |
| | Ross |
Ayers | Lucy's schoolmate |
| 8 | Kathleen |
Chase | Lucy's mother |
| | Arya |
Stark | Resident |
| | Joanna |
Clarkson | In the neighborhood |
| | Dale |
| Mayor of Plumpton |
| | Nina |
Garcia | Lucy's schoolmate |
| 9 | Jill |
Lopez | Wedding night of wedding |
| | Emmett |
Chapman | Close friend of Lucy in H.S. |
| 10 |
Paige | |
Ben's assistant |
| | Colin |
Dunn | Savannah's fiancé |
| 11 |
Chris | Evans |
Resident |
| | Ronan |
Farrow | Resident |
| 12 |
Aunt Janice | |
Driving in from Houston |
| | Uncle Keith |
| Driving in from Houston |
| | Ashley |
| Driving in from Houston |
| | Brian |
| Driving in from Houston |
| | Aunt Karen |
| Driving in from Houston |
| | Marian |
| Kathleen's friend, red hair |
| | Betsy |
| Kathleen's friend, curley gray hair |
| | Peggy |
| Kathleen's friend short woman |
| | Janet |
| Kathleen's friend, new |
| 13 |
Stephanie | Gantz |
Lived near Lucy and Matt |
| | Kyle |
Porter | Lives in Austin |
| 15 |
Beverly | Moore |
Lucy's grandmother |
| 17 |
William | |
Bartender knows the Chases |
| 22 |
Mojo | Garcia |
Nina Garcia's child |
| | John |
Garcia | Nina Garcia's child |
| | Chris |
Garcia | Nina Garcia's child |
| 29 |
Troy | Henderson |
Guy Savvy said she killed |
| 31 |
Julia | Gardner |
Matt's second wife |
| 43 |
Trudy | |
Meeting Planner at Byrd Estate |
