| 1 | Claire |
Scott | Waiting at bar for husband |
| | Paul |
Scott | Late for meeting |
| | Ava |
Guilgord | Claire's professor |
| 2 | Lydia |
Delgado | Dee's mother |
| | Mindy |
Parker | Another mother |
| | Dee |
Delgado | Lydia's daughter |
| | Bella |
Wilson | Dee's best friend |
| | Penelope |
Ward | Cheerleader's mother |
| | Coach |
Henley | Girls' coach |
| | Rebecca |
Thistlewaite | Classmate |
| | Branch |
Ward | Penelope Ward's husband |
| | Anna |
Kilpatrick | Missing Girl |
| | Rick |
Butler | Lydia's boyfrend |
| | Lloyd |
| Dee's biographical father |
| | Sally |
| Julia's friend works at record store |
| | Carleen |
Loper | Desk monitor Lipscomb Hall |
| | Nancy |
Grigos | Julia's roommate |
| | Veronica |
Voorhees | Julia ate lunch with |
| | Ezekiel |
Mann | Julia shot pool with |
| | David |
Conford | Sat on couches with |
| | Michael |
Stipe | Lead singer REM |
| | John |
MacCallister | Front Door Manhattan |
| | Beth |
Tindall | Night Desk Monitor Lipscomb |
| 3 | Ginny |
| Claire's gradmother |
| | Adam |
Quinn | Paul's partner at firm |
| | Helen |
Reid | Claire's mother |
| | Tim |
| Bartender |
| | Jacob |
Mayhew | Captain of Police |
| | Johnny |
Jackson | Congressman |
| | Fred |
Nolan | Security |
| | Pia |
Lorite | Claire's insurance agent |
| | Eric |
Rayman | Detective In Claire's house |
| 4 | Julia |
Carroll | Lydia's sister missing |
| | Sam |
Carroll | Lydia's father |
| | Sheila |
Quinn | Adam Quinn's wife |
| | Kerry |
Lascala | Friend of Julia |
| | Harvey |
Falke | Detective Works with Mayhew |
| | Abigail |
Ellis | Missing girl |
| | Samantha |
Findlay | Missing girl |
| 8 | Allison |
Hendrickson | Claire's doubles partner |
| 9 | Leslie |
Lewis | Raped woman |
| | Pam |
Clayton | Raped woman |
| | Buckminister |
Fuller | Paul's childhood home |
| | Lexie |
| Lives in small home with Paul |
| | Wynn |
Wallace | Claire's attorney,The Colonel |
| | Bob |
Kilpatrick | Anna's father |
| | Eleanor |
Kilpatrick | Anna's mother |
| | Timothy |
McCorquodale | Executed for killing white girl |
| | Ben |
Carver | Murdered 6 young men |
| 11 |
Gerald | Scott |
Paul's father |
| | Bartlesby |
| Nickname for Paul |
| 12 |
Darryl | Lassiter |
Sheriff blames videos on |
| 14 |
Joanne Rebecca | Greenfield |
Killed by Daryl Lassiter |
| | Victoria Kathryn |
Massey | Killed by Daryl Lassiter |
| | Denise Elizabeth |
Adams | Killed by Daryl Lassiter |
| | Brent |
Lockwood | Julia's first boyfriend |
