| 1 | Officer |
Bowman | The officer who rescued Mary. |
| | Tall-and-Wiry |
| The paramedic. |
| 2 | Wayne |
Boone | Mary's father. |
| | Mary Ellen |
Boone | Protagonist and narrator. |
| 3 | Mark |
Roane | The sheriff. |
| | Andrew |
Carter | One of the protagonist, Lola's boyfriend. |
| | Lola Elizabeth |
Scott | Drew's missing girlfriend. |
| | Max |
| Drew's cousin. |
| | Mr. |
Scott | Lola's father. |
| | Mrs. |
Scott | Lola's mother. |
| 4 | Autumn |
| Lola's bestfriend. Sheriff's daughter. |
| 7 | Mr. |
Moore | Drew's history teacher. |
| 10 |
Nana | |
A store owner. |
| | Eloise |
| The counter lady. |
| | Sandra |
| The waitress at Waybrooke's diner. |
| 13 |
Ben | Hooper |
Wayne and Mary's new neighbor. |
| 16 |
Diana | |
The woman who called to tipline. |
| | Meredith |
Hoyt | The woman who saw lola. |
| | Savannah |
Bateman | Roane's associate. |
| 21 |
Eloise | |
The woman at Nana's. |
| 24 |
Redhead | |
A police officer. |
| | McCurry |
| One of the officer. |
| | Bowman |
| A younger officer. |
| 25 |
Alison | |
One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Krissy |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Courtney |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Arely |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Bekah |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Carly |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Sheena |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| | Ashley |
| One of the girls that Wayne kidnapped. |
| 29 |
Mrs. | Hooper |
Ben's wife. |
| | Madison |
Perkins | Mary's real identity. |
