| | | | Part 1 |
| 1 | Matthew | Crimstein | Naomi's friend. |
| | Ryan | | Crash's friend. |
| | Trevor | | Crash's friend. |
| | Carter | | Crash's friend. |
| | Crash | Maynard | Naomi and Matthew's rich classmate. |
| | Naomi | Pine | The bullied girl. Missing. |
| | Mrs. | Walsh | Naomi's former teacher. |
| 2 | Hester | Crimstein | Matthew's grandmother. A lawyer. |
| | Hipster | Pundit | The TV Judge. AKA: Chad, Rick. |
| | Prepster | Host | The TV host. |
| | Simon | Greene | Hester's client. |
| | Aaron | Corval | The drug addict that Simon punched. |
| | Rusty | Eggers | Presidential candidate. |
| | David | Crimstein | Matthew's father. |
| | Laila | Crimstein | Matthew's mother. |
| 3 | Tim | | Hester's long-time driver. |
| | Ira | Crimstein | Hester's husband. |
| | Jeffrey | Crimstein | Hester's oldest son. |
| | Sandy | | Jeffrey's 4th wife. |
| | Eric | Crimstein | Hester's middle child. |
| | Stacey | | Eric's wife. |
| 4 | Oren | Carmichael | Westville Police Chief. |
| | Cheryl | | Oren's ex-wife. |
| | Wilde | | David's best friend. A private investigator. |
| | Bernard | Pine | Naomi's father. |
| | Pia | | Naomi's mother. |
| 5 | Rola | | Wilde's foster sister. |
| | Darla | | One of Naomi's classmates. |
| | Ava | O'Brien | The assistant art teacher. |
| 6 | Lori | | On-Duty hairstylist. |
| | Bryan | | Hester's makeup artist. |
| | Allison | Grant | Hester's segment producer. |
| 7 | Dash | Maynard | Crash's father. |
| | Kyle | | Crash's friend. |
| | Luke | | One of Crash's friends. |
| | Mason | Perdue | One of Crash's friends. |
| | Kaitlin | | One of Crash's friends. |
| | Sutton | Holmes | One of Crash's friends. |
| | Caleb | | One of Crash's friends. |
| | Brianna | | Caleb's girlfriend. |
| | Rosa | | Crash's maid. |
| 8 | Delia | Maynard | Crash's mother. |
| | Kiera | Maynard | Crash's sister. |
| | Kara | Maynard | Kiera's twin. |
| | Gavin | Chambers | A private security. |
| 10 | Anders | Ericcson | A psychologist. |
| | Malcolm | Gladwell | The man who popularized Ericcson's theory. |
| 11 | Larry | Pine | Naomi's uncle. |
| | | | Part 2 |
| 13 | Saul | Strauss | A famed activist/attorney. Hester's guest. |
| | Arnie | Poplin | One of Saul's sources. |
| 18 | Sarah | McLynn | Hester's assistant. |
| | Brewers | | Wilde's foster parents. |
| | Thor | | The Maynard's security. |
| 21 | Sandra | | Wilde's friend. |
| 26 | Aaron | Gerios | A former FBI special agent. |
| 27 | Chloe | | The Brewers's dog. |
| | Zelda | | Rola's security. |
| 31 | Jan | Schnall | Rusty's top aide. |
| | Lia | Capasso | Rusty's top aide. |
| | Scott | Gallett | The anchorman. |
| | Kandi | Pate | The young star. |
| 33 | Raymond | Stark | Murdered. |
| | Christopher | Anson | Raymond's victim. |
| | Kindler | | A detective. |
| 35 | Nathan | Goldstein | Pia's son. |
| | Harry | Goldstein | Pia's new husband. |
