| 1 | Bobby | McGowan | Robert Francis
McGowan III Narrator |
| | Jenny | McGowan | Bobby's sister,
2 years younger |
| | Rick | Fields | Bobby's Mom's
brother |
| | Yvonne | Fields | Bobby's Mom's
sister |
| 2 | Heather | Fields/McGowan | Bobby's
Mom |
| | Roy | Cooper | Ex-boyfriend of
Heather |
| 3 | Jim | Broadhurst | Owned roofing
company |
| 4 | Vance | | Worked for roofer,
left in picture |
| | Lyle | Taft | Worked for roofer,
looking at Heather |
| 5 | Kim | Crabtree | Works for Santa
Barbara News Press |
| | Mr. | Jenkins | General Manager
KEYT Channel 3 |
| 6 | Kelsey | | Cashier at grocery
store |
| 7 | Justin | Ridgely | Jenny's husband |
| 8 | Mark | Patchett | Lead
investigator Heather's murder |
| 9 | Mrs. | Engelbrecht | McGowan's
neighbor across the street |
| | Austin | Ridgely | Jenny's son |
| | Avery | Ridgely | Jenny's daughter |
| | Ivy | Harrington | Bobby had 3
year relationship |
| | Angie | McGowan | Bobby's Dad's
second wife |
| 10 | Barbara | Palatino | Mother of
classmates |
| | Victor | Tribe | Heather's old
boyfriend |
| | Ty | Brownstone | Alibi for Roy
Cooper |
| | Ethan | Drury | Alibi for Roy
Cooper |
| 11 | Conrad | Drury | Ethan's little
brother |
| 16 | Everett | Taft | Real name of
Lyle Taft |
| 17 | Griffin | | Lives in Heather's
childhood home |
| | Mrs. | Ruskin | Neighbor from
Bobby's childhood |
| | | Englerts | Bought home from
grandparents |
| | Nina | | Mrs. Ruskin's caretaker |
| | Freddy | Ruskin | Mrs. Ruskin's
son |
| | Bill | Maker | Weird neighbor, a
twin |
| | Mott | Larson | Friend of Heather,
lived across the street |
| 24 | Marcus | Young | Conrad's
co-worker |
| | Dale | Collier | Victim of Conrad,
convicted of murder |
| 26 | Gus | Wilkinson | McGowan's old
neighbor |
| 29 | Victoria | Bosco | Conrad's
victim |
| 31 | Frederick | Frick | Ventura
detective |
| 32 | Angie | Billows | Murdered by
Conrad |
| | Jill | Venable | Murdered by
Conrad |
| | Greta | Smith | Murdered by
Conrad |
| | Bobbie | Sax | Murdered by Conrad |
| | Jessica | Moore | Murdered by
Conrad |
| | Patricia | Patterson | Murdered by
Conrad |
| | Derek | Tice | Convicted of Mary
Jane Cushing murder |
| | Rog | Thurl | Innocent man
convicted of murder |
| 33 | Sissy | Trafalgar | Killed in
2006 San Luis Obispo |
| | Brynn | Markinson | Killed in 2001
Santa Maria |
| | Mary Jane | Cushing | Killed in
2005 Pismo Beach by Conrad |
| | Evelyn | Cushing | Mary Jane
Cushing's mother |
| | Rachel | Tatum | Defending Derek
Tice |
| 35 | Archie | | Name used by Conrad
on dating app |
| 39 | Cameron | Edding | Conrad framed
for killing Lily Spector |
| | Lily | Spector | Cameron Edding's
girl friend, murdered by Conrad |
| 42 | Norm | Unger | Accused of killing
Grace Goodall |
| | Grace | Goodall | Killed in 2011
St. Luis Obispo |
| | Janet | | Grace Goodall's mother |
| | Wyatt | Trimble | Traveling drug
dealer |
| | Gilford | Moore | "Wyatt" bought
land from Gilford |
| 47 | Harold | | Conrad's loud friend
at bar |
| 48 | Wade | McCarthy | San Luis
Obispo prosecutor |
| | Karl | Kimmers | Runs a true crime
website |
| 49 | Helen | Nevelle | Evelyn
Cushing's sister |
| 50 | Kathryn | | Bartender at
Harry's Nightclub |
| 52 | Adam | Bickford | Ricky's friend |
| | Penelope | Chalk | Adam dated |
| | Harry | Covington | Works at
Amtrak, hates Conrad |
| 53 | Ginny | Towers | Dated Cameron,
killed by Conrad |
| | Zed | Billings | Lily's
ex-husband, convicted of murder |
| 57 | Delmut | Reed | Sold Conrad old
truck |
| | Tim | Miller | Conrad's alias |
| | Peggy | | Cashier at grocery
store |
| 58 | Colin | Davidson | Santa Barbara
police department |
| 62 | Prudence | | 70 year old works
at grocery |
| | Dale | Duncan | Neighbor of Conrad
in Arkansas |
| 66 | Alexis | | Bobby met in rehab |
| | William | Ryan | Stranger Bobby
met in Costco |
| | Annie | Ryan | Little girl
missing, 12 years old |
