| 1 | April |
Hamilton | Protagonist |
| | Xavier |
| April's temporary boyfriend, Theo's friend |
| | Jeanie |
| April's aunt |
| | Katie |
| April's cousin, Jeanie's daughter |
| | Tess |
Hamilton | April's sister |
| 2 | Theo |
Banks | A bartender, April's pretend boyfriend to avoid family's matchmaking |
| | Lori |
| Theo's regular customer |
| 3 | Claire |
| April's close friend |
| | Cole |
| A talent agent, April's friend |
| | Linis |
| A mortgage banker |
| | Calvin |
| The man who runs the hardware store |
| | Cory |
| Tess's husband |
| | Brody |
| The basement dweller |
| | Landon |
| April's ex-boyfriend |
| 4 | Addison |
| The girl Theo owes a debt |
| 5 | Tom |
| An actor |
| | Claire |
| Tom's partner |
| 6 | Jared |
| Theo's brother-like friend |
| | Mr. |
Boyle | Theo's neighbor |
| | Heath |
| Theo's brother |
| | Lacey |
| Heath's new girlfriend |
| 7 | Mitch |
Hamilton | April's brother |
| | George |
Strait | American singer |
| 8 | Pamela |
Hamilton | April's mother |
| | Josh |
Hamilton | April's father |
| | Candace |
| Mitch's wife |
| 12 |
Greg | |
Auntie Jeanie's husband |
| 13 |
Emma | Hamilton |
Mitch's daughter, April's niece |
| | Richelle |
| The market researcher |
| | Bob |
Moore | Josh's best friend |
| 14 |
Dean | Moore |
April's high school friend, Bob's son |
| 15 |
Libby | |
April's niece |
| 18 |
Carol | Moore |
Bob's wife |