| 1 | Lottie |
Jones | Protagonist; retired serial killer. Aka:Lorena Mae Lansdale |
| | Plum |
Dixon | Producer at Reboot Productions |
| 3 | Archie |
Jones | Lottie's son. Aka: Richard Lansdale |
| | Richard |
Lansdale | Alias of Archie Jones |
| | Morgan |
| Archie's girlfriend; pregnant |
| | Stephanie |
| Archie's ex-wife |
| 4 | Lorena Mae |
Lansdale | One of Lottie's victims |
| | Kenneth |
Burke | Detective who interrogated Lottie in 1985 |
| | Cole |
Fletcher | Plum's boyfriend |
| 5 | Glenda |
| Event coordinator |
| | Sheila |
| Lottie's bingo playmate |
| | Bonnie |
| Lottie's bingo playmate |
| | Janice |
| Lottie's bingo playmate |
| | Doug |
| Pastor; Lottie's friend |
| | Hector |
| Assistant pastor |
| | Danielle |
| Bonnie's son |
| 6 | Ernie |
| Computer store clerk |
| 7 | Paul |
Norris | One of Lottie's victims |
| | Marilyn |
Dobbs | One of Lottie's victims |
| | Walter |
Simmons | One of Lottie's victims |
| 8 | Sandra |
| Sheila's sister |
| | Noah |
| Lottie's grandson |
| 9 | Rey |
Tula | Detective in charge of Plum's murder case |
| | Kelsie |
Harlow | Detective Tula's partner |
| 11 |
Gary | |
Archie's father; Lottie's former lover |
| 12 |
Jaxon | |
Bank representative |
| 15 |
Olive | |
Lottie's granddaughter |
| | Simon |
| Archie's best friend |
| | Lucas |
| Archie's friend |
| 17 |
Mr. | Porter |
One of Lottie's friends |
| | Dorie |
| One of Lottie's friends |
| 19 |
Dr. | Maraj |
Lottie's doctor |
| | Valerie |
| Parishioner who had hip replacement |
| 24 |
Ray | Lansdale |
Lottie's father |
| | Molly |
| Lottie's childhood best friend |
| | Diane |
| Lottie's childhood friend |
| 25 |
Geoff | Burns |
Detective Tula's former partner |
| | Arnold |
Harlow | Kelsie's father |
| | Ellen |
Harlow | Kelsie's mother |
| | Marion |
Harlow | Kelsie's aunt |
| 28 |
Tom | Wallace |
Resident of Oak Manor Senior Living |
| | Dana |
Ferris | Sales director at Serenity Village |
| 29 |
Norma | Dixon |
Plum's mother |
| 30 |
Richard | Ramirez |
Serial killer known as the Night Stalker |
| | Mrs. |
Lockland | Most devout member of First Covenant |
| 36 |
Janet | |
Lottie's only real friend |
| | Miss |
Marcia | Sales director at Tranquil Towers |
| 37 |
Chuck | Warwick |
One of Lottie's victims |
| 49 |
Pastor | Matthews |
Former pastor |
| 52 |
Delia | Crane |
Top real estate agent |
| 59 |
Kelvin | |
Delia's assistant |
| 61 |
Monica | |
Backpacker |
| 63 |
Burke | Junior |
Kenneth Burke's son |
| 66 |
Misty | |
Nurse practitioner |
| 67 |
Wanda | |
Police secretary who believes Lottie is innocent |
