| 1 | Madison |
Dalrymple | Missing. |
| | Cheyenne |
Baker | Madison's friend, Missing. |
| | Hannah |
| Madison's step-mother. |
| | Emmy Lou |
Clifton-Lang | Hannah's bestfriend, Police officer. |
| | Mr. |
Baker | Cheyenne's father. |
| | Rihanna |
| American singer. |
| | Gerald |
Clifton | The sheriff, Emmy's father. |
| | Brett |
Temple | A police officer. |
| | Mr. |
Singh | A hardware store owner. |
| | Jonah |
Lang | Emmy's husband. |
| 2 | Cole |
| Emmy and Jonah's son. |
| | Vanna |
Temple | Brett's pregnant wife. |
| | Taybee |
Clifton-Clifton | Emmy's cousin, A lawyer. |
| | Myrna |
Clifton | Emmy's mother. |
| | Tommy |
Clifton | Emmy's brother. |
| | Henry |
Clifton | Emmy's brother, Deceased. |
| | Martha |
Clifton | Emmy's sister. |
| | Celia |
Clifton | Tommy's wife. |
| | Sylvia |
Wrigley | The editor of the local paper. |
| | Lance |
Culpepper | A courthouse clerk. |
| | Dervla |
Culpepper | Lance's wife. |
| | Hugo |
Sanders | Angela's wife. |
| | Angela |
Sanders | Hugo's husband. |
| | Tyler |
Sanders | Hugo and Angela's son. |
| | Paul |
Dalrymple | Madison's father. |
| | Davey |
| Hannah's son. |
| 3 | Barb |
| Hannah's aunt. |
| | Virgil |
Ingram | The chief deputy. |
| | Felix |
Baker | Cheyenne's father. |
| | Ruth |
Baker | Cheyenne's mother. |
| | Pamela |
Baker | Cheyenne's sister. |
| | Jack |
Whitlock | Cheyenne's boyfriend. |
| 4 | Carl |
Whitlock | A pedetrician, Jack's father. |
| | Monica |
Whitlock | Carl's wife, Jack's mother. |
| | Dylan |
Alvarez | Sheriff's resource officer. |
| | Rex |
Delilah | A Facebook page owner that Jack looks into. |
| | Wesley |
Woodrow | A gangster-type student, Drug dealer. Aka: Woody. |
| | The |
Perv | A possible druge dealer. |
| | Kaitlynn |
| One of the popular girls, Taybee's daughter. |
| | Ashleigh |
| One of the popular girls. |
| | Brandi |
| One of the popular girls. |
| | Connor |
| One of the popular girls. |
| 5 | Mrs. |
Burroughs | Cheyenne and Madison's teacher. |
| | Dr. |
Hardy | Chemistry teacher. |
| | Dale |
Loudermilk | The choir leader. |
| | Jenna |
Loudermilk | Dale's daughter. |
| | Millie |
Clifton | Emmy's aunt. |
| 6 | Lionel |
Faulkner | FBI agent. |
| | Esther |
Loudermilk | Dale's wife. |
| | Irma |
Woodrow | Woody's grandmother. |
| | Louise |
Good | Emmy's childhood friend. |
| | Michael |
Berry-Lawhorn | Special Agent. |
| | Adam |
Huntsinger | Walton's son, The real "The Perv". |
| 7 | Walton |
Huntsinger | Adam's father. |
| | Alma |
Huntsinger | Adam's mother. |
| | Terrell |
| Taybee's husband. |
| |
| | 12 Years Later |
| 8 | Cleet |
| Myrna's handyman, Deceased. |
| | Barbara |
Jericho | An exotic dancer who was raped. |
| | Paisley |
Walker | Missing. |
| 9 | Freddy Frederick Arnold |
Henley | A child murderer. |
| | Jude |
Archer | Special Agent in charge on Henley's case. |
| | Darlene |
Talbot | One of Henley's victims, never found. |
| | Raheem |
Davidson | FBI Special Agent. |
| | Lara |
Talbot | Darlene's mother. |
| | Chaz |
Hollister | Jude's boss. |
| 10 |
Elijah | Walker |
Paisley's father. |
| | Carol |
Walker | Paisley's mother. |
| | Anthony |
Ramirez | A landscaper, Possible suspect. |
| | Seth |
Alexander | Emmy's colleague. |
| | Reggie |
McAllister | Convicted, Carol's brother. |
| | Damien |
Reynolds | Emmy's tech guy. |
| | Sherry |
Robertson | GBI Field Agent. |
| | Milo |
Kinley | The funeral director. |
| | Trixie |
| Elijah's paid girl. |
| 13 |
Nate | Trask |
The priest. |
| | Ms. |
Heller | Paisley's favorite teacher. |
| 14 |
Belinda | Pfeiffer |
The woman on Elijah's phone. |
| | Misty |
Norris | Elijah's secretary. |
| | Daphne |
Pfeiffer | Belinda's mother. |
| 15 |
Cynthia | |
Taybee's mother. |
| | Ruel |
| Taybee's father. |
| | Penley |
| Jude's uncle. |
| 16 |
Bubba | Rawley |
The man that Martha hit. |
| | Barb |
| Hannah's aunt. |
