| | | | Part 1 |
| 1 | Allison | Bennett | Jason and Lucinda's daughter who got shot. Aka: Al, Alsford. |
| | Ethan | Bennett | Jason and Lucinda's son. |
| | Moonie | | Jason's white mutt. |
| | Lucinda | Bennett | Jason's wife. |
| | Jason | Bennett | Protagonist. |
| | Arielle | | A hockey player. |
| | Emily | | A hockey player. |
| | Brianna | McKinney | Allison's schoolmate. |
| | Ron | McKinney | Brianna's father. |
| 2 | Caitlin | Romarin | Lucinda's sister. |
| | Courtney | Deluca | Melissa's daughter. Allison's friend. |
| | Troy | | Allison's boyfriend. |
| 3 | Bill | Wolloughby | The detective of Chester County. |
| | Jim | Balleu | Bill's partner. |
| | Mark | Chen | The head of emergency surgery. |
| 4 | Melissa | Deluca | Lucinda's best friend. |
| | Dom | Kingston | An FBI special agent. |
| | Michael | Hallman | Dom's partner. Aka: Wiki. |
| 5 | John | Milo | Allison's murderer. |
| | George | Veria Jr. | John's accomplice. Deceased. Aka: Junior. |
| | Walter | Jersey | A drug dealer. The man that John and Junior killed. |
| | George | Veria Sr. | Junior's father. Aka: Big George. |
| 8 | Joe | Watanabe | The case agent. |
| | Matt | Reilly | The laboring oar. |
| 9 | Daniel | Mozer | One of Milo's victims. |
| | Jay | Gold | The district attorney. |
| | Paul | Hart | Milo's lawyer. |
| 10 | Max | | The Bennett's cat. |
| 12 | Marie | | Jason's officer manager. |
| 13 | Rebecca | Robertson | Lucinda's summer intern. |
| | Seamus | Deluca | Melissa's husband. |
| 14 | Richard | Volkov | Dom's boss. Aka: Gremmie. |
| | William | Bennett | Jason's father. |
| | Milton | Hershey | The owner of Hershey's Chocolate. |
| | Tig | | Dom's uncle. |
| | Denise | Kingston | Dom's wife. |
| 16 | Devi | Gupta | An FBI special agent. |
| 18 | Zack | | One of Ethan's friends. |
| | Christopher | | One of Ethan's friends. |
| | Scott | | One of Ethan's friends. |
| | Miles | | Ethan's classmate. |
| 19 | Claire | Romarin | Lucinda's mother. |
| 24 | Bryan | Krieger | The man who wrote rumors about Jason. |
| 25 | Lingermann | | An FBI special agent. |
| | Susan | | Claire's favorite nurse. |
| 27 | Justine | | Jason's officemate. |
| 32 | Pam | Hart | Paul's wife. |
| | | | Part 2 |
| 33 | Mr. | Thatcher | Jason's neighbor. |
| 39 | Ed | | The body shop owner. |
| 40 | Remy | Whitman | A towing service owner. |
| | David | Fishman | A lawyer. |
| | Contessa | | Paula's girlfriend. |
| 42 | Mike | Ricks | The senator. |
| | Barbara | Caldwell | The representative. |
| | Phillip | Nerone | The BMW driver. Aka: North Philly Phil. |
| 47 | Linda | | The waitress. |
| | Jaybird | | The man that Milo shot. |
| | Kyle | | One of the truckers. |
| 51 | Rohan | Doha | The man that Mr. Ricks
allegedly killed. |
| | William | Diebold | A military interrogators. |
| | Martin | Tornott | William's partner. |
| | Sam | | Jason's colleague. |
| | Rowena | | Jason's colleague. |
| 54 | Carl | | One of Milo's men. |
| | David | | One of Milo's men. |
| 56 | Flossie | Bergstrom | One of the truckers. The woman who helped Jason. |
| | Manny | | One of Flossie's dogs. |
| | Moe | | One of Flossie's dogs. |
| | Jack | | One of Flossie's dogs. |
| | John | | Flossie's husband. Deceased. |
| 58 | Mary | Ward | A retired library aide. Tig's acquaintance. |
| | Leonard | Richardson | Tig's friend. |
| | Skeet | Dunwoody | Leonard's friend. |
| 66 | Rob | Froman | The U.S. attorney for Eastern District. |
| | John | Colasante | A court reporter. Jason's friend. |
